The Burial at Thebes

In: English and Literature

Submitted By brmbrm89
Words 1668
Pages 7
Bianca Meier
C788603X
Assignment 06
Option 2 Seamus Heaney’s The Burial at Thebes
How does Heaney attempt to make his play, as a reworking of an ancient Greek play written by Sophocles, relevant to a modern audience more than 2000 years later? How far do you think he has succeeded?
Seamus Heaney’s The Burial at Thebes is a reworking of Sophocles’ play Antigone from over two thousand years ago. In many ways The Burial at Thebes aims to rework the ancient Greek tragedy to make it relevant to a modern audience. This essay firstly analyses the challenges Heaney faced during the process of translation and writing including his own conscious effort to make the play suitable for a contemporary audience. Secondly, it describes how Heaney’s use of language aided in presenting modern ideas through poetic timbre and language, Irish diction and English idiom in an attempt to make the play more ‘speakable’. Thirdly, this essay identifies features of Greek theatrical conventions and how Heaney used these to shape his play. Heaney also presents social and political issues through The Burial at Thebes in a way that resonates with a contemporary audience.
Vital to understanding the challenges Heaney faced in his work, is his own assertion that his work is not a translation of an ancient Greek text but rather a version of it essentially because he drew from the existing translations by Jebb and the Loeb (Heaney, 2004, in Hardwick, 2008, p.222). For Heaney, it is imperative to be aware of tradition and the past, but not to be bound by it, because to do so would make progress and change impossible, “the problem is if you look at a verse translation–or a very good verse translation, you know –immediately, diction is always crucial, choice of words, you know, and so on. And you’re yearning for the right one. Then you see it in somebody else’s and that’s very dangerous stuff…...

Similar Documents

Living in Ancient Egypt at Thebes in 2000 B.C.

... I think we (The American People) have amnesia when it comes to history. We often forget about the past and we very rarely apply what we have learned to future decisions. There are individuals who use their past mistakes as education building blocks. This is true on an individual basis more so than a country basis. When the American people think, they think only of themselves and what’s in it for them. They want it now and not later, they’re not willing to wait. When a politician comes along with charisma and charm and offers change, the American people are quick to believe a lie. Because they think of how it will make life easier for themselves often disregarding their Christian values and the consequences the candidate’s policies will have on America. An example of this type of dictator socialist style president can be recognized by studying the history of how Germany came to power under Hitler. Germany's economy was in disarray and shambles but the Rhetoric of an evil leader in Hitler, was believed by Ungodly or ignorant men. Women and young people. These are the people that brought Hitler to power. The same scenario took place with the Election of Obama in both terms. And we see his socialist style of leadership today. Often disregarding the constitution of our United States of America and pushing his own agenda through the powers of executive orders and the corrupt Supreme Court.  God is slowly lifting his Grace from America we see it every day. But there is always hope...

Words: 960 - Pages: 4

Home Burial

...in his poem “Home Burial” how even though the husband and wife are both grieving for the death of their child, they each handle their grief in different ways. “Home Burial” revolves around a husband and wife who are at opposition over how to deal with the death of their child. The entire scene in the poem takes place on a staircase. At the beginning, the wife, Amy, is at the top of the stairs and her husband is at the bottom. By the end of the poem, he is at the top of the stairs and she is at the bottom. The opposite’s ends of the staircase represent the conflicting ways they deal with their grief. Amy expresses her grief with Amy is suffering from extreme sorrow over the loss of her first born child and is unable to stop grieving. Her grief causes her to lash out at her husband because she feels he is being insensitive and unaffected by the death of their child. Amy first begins to feel as if her husband’s grief was not as great as hers when she saw him “making the gravel leap and leap in air”. Amy feels that if her husband had any feelings at all that he would not have been able to dig their own child’s grave. She no longer knows this man who can dig their child’s grave and then come in and “talk about everyday concerns.” She does not understand how he can make small talk about things when their child has just died. As he talks, she thinks “he still had “the fresh earth from your own baby’s grave. “ The husband in “Home Burial is suffering in......

Words: 552 - Pages: 3

Thebes

...The Pharaohs of Egypt Old ,middle and New Kingdom pharaohs were responsible for the creation of one of the greatest civilizations in humans history. There contribution’s to art ,artitecture,city planning, and government continue to affect us today .The three pharaohs who had the greatest impact on Egypt were pepi II ,RamessesII, Hatshepsut. The Pharaoh that ruled the new kingdom was Ramesses II.Ramesses II was famous for his bravery. RamessesII had lots of wives. He had a total of 52 sons. Ramesses’ bravery was released when he fought in a battle with the Hittites. Ramesses also went to battle with his pet lion .When he gets back from the battle he is so proud that he won the fight he chiseled his name on everything. He also built his temple at Abu Simbel in the south. Pepi II ruled at only 4 years old. Pepi lived long and ruled for 94 years. Pepi’s regent from Kush wrote to him saying I’m bringing you back a pygmy. Pepi II then writes back saying bring him back safe. He was too weak to lead his army. Pepi II was the last pharaoh to come from the Old Kingdom. The pharaoh that started the first destiny was Narmer. He was from the Old Kingdom in 3100 B, C. E. He united Upper and Lower Egypt. Narmer wore the double crown. He created the Narmer Palette. It was made out of slate (a type of stone).His own symbol was a bull.......

Words: 303 - Pages: 2

Antegone

...ANTIGONE Antigone is a tragedy by Sophocles written in or before 441 BC. Chronologically, it is the third of the three Theban plays but was written first. The play expands on the Theban legend that predated it and picks up where Aeschylus' Seven Against Thebes ends. This play is based on the life story of Antigone, the daughter of Oeudipe and Jocaste. It is a legend of her sacrifice for her loved ones, her believes and her honour. Antigone’s brother Polynice had betrayed his country and died during the war. Creon, the king of Thebes had refused to give him a burial. Antigone is outraged by this decision and goes as far as sacrificing her life, to give her brother a burial he deserves. Even law of the king does not stop her from doing what she thinks is right. Antigone is the tragic heroine of the play and this play revolves around her struggle against the autocratic laws of the state. Even she manages to give Polynice a rightful burial but, this burial costs Antigone her life. SYNOPSIS In the beginning of the play, two brothers leading opposite sides in Thebes' civil war died fighting each other for the throne. Creon, the new ruler of Thebes, has decided that Eteocles will be honored and Polyneices will be in public shame. The rebel brother's body will not be sanctified by holy rites, and will lie unburied on the battlefield, prey for carrion animals like worms and vultures, the harshest punishment at the time. Antigone and Ismene are the sisters of the dead Polyneices...

Words: 2726 - Pages: 11

Citique on Oepidus

...Oedipus insists that Tiresias tell Thebes what he knows. Provoked by the anger and insults of Oedipus, Tiresias begins to hint at his knowledge. Finally, when Oedipus furiously accuses Tiresias of the murder, Tiresias tells Oedipus that Oedipus himself is the curse.” In this section, the characteristic swiftness of Oedipus’s thought, words, and action begins to work against him. When Tiresias arrives at line 340, Oedipus praises him as an all-powerful seer who has shielded Thebes from many a plague. Only forty lines later, he refers to Tiresias as “scum” and soon after that accuses him of treason. Oedipus sizes up a situation, makes a judgment, and acts all in an instant. While this confident expedience was laudable in the first section, it is exaggerated to a point of near absurdity in the second. Oedipus asks Tiresias and Creon questions are his typical mode of address and frequently a sign of his quick and intelligent mind but they are merely rhetorical, for they accuse and presume rather than seek answers. Though Tiresias has laid the truth out plainly before Oedipus, the only way Oedipus can interpret the prophet’s words is as an attack, and his quest for information only seeks to confirm what he already believes. Antigone’s major conflict is between Creon and Antigone. Creon has declared that the body of Polynices may not be given a proper burial because he led the forces that invaded Thebes, but Antigone wishes to give her brother a proper burial nevertheless. The......

Words: 490 - Pages: 2

Translating Present Dna to Life in 2000 Bc Thebes

...In visualizing myself transporting back in time to 2000 BC Thebes Egypt while maintaining my present genetic composition, gender, family and social status; there would be similarities in addition to advantages and disadvantages. I am a woman, a widow, mother, grandmother, proprietress, and social advocate. I, my son, my daughter, and her twin daughters live within the same household. Each of us inherited equal portions of their father’s estate and my daughter inherited her late husband’s property. The information afore mentioned would be in Egypt as it is in the present. In Egyptian society women enjoyed considerable legal rights and were afforded the possibility of economic independence. My daughter could have managed the household by delegating responsibility and hiring an overseer for our agricultural business. As a grandmother I would as I do now, lavish adoration on my granddaughters and share my wisdom with them. My son is an intellectual and philosopher; he would have been receiving an education in Alexandria. My gifts of time management, linguistics, and advocate for the socially disadvantaged could have been translated into Egyptian society. Women could inaugurate court cases, act as witnesses, and handle legal documents and transactions. There were no restrictions on the amount of property and other amenities that a woman, married or unmarried, could own. Throughout history the women in our family have never been subjected to illiteracy. Although......

Words: 304 - Pages: 2

Egyptian Burial Rites

...The Egyptian's burial rituals were more focus on the path to the after life, than the actual after life itself. There was three different types of burials that was performed based on how affordable it was. Everyone had deserved one, even if you were too poor to pay for one of the three you still was able to have some form of one to go to the afterlife. Even the mourning was dramatic according to Herodotus (413 BCE), they would plaster their faces in mud, leave the dead with relatives and then wear a girdle while beating themselves on the chest. Mourning was sorrowful but it was to hope the dead would find eternal bliss. Mummification was practiced around 3500 BCE, because they had believed that the dead needed a body to go onto the afterlife in. According to Mark, "The soul was thought to consist of nine separate parts: the Khat was the physical body; the Ka one’s double-form; the Ba a human-headed bird aspect which could speed between earth and the heavens; Shuyet was the shadow self; Akh the immortal, transformed self, Sahuand Sechem aspects of the Akh; Ab was the heart, the source of good and evil; Ren was one’s secret name." Because of these nine parts, they lead to the reasoning behind why they needed to preserve the body. Also during this time it should that Egypt had created a complex form of the soul for their time. But their wealth decided their mummification process. They also decided what the body would be put in to. The first process was the most expensive for......

Words: 1111 - Pages: 5

Oedipus Rex Summary

...Oedipus Rex or Oedipus the King Summary When the play opens, Thebes is suffering a plague which leaves its fields and women barren. Oedipus, the king of Thebes, has sent his brother-in-law, Creon, to the house of Apollo to ask the oracle how to end the plague. Creon returns, bearing good news: once the killer of the previous king, Laius, is found, Thebes will be cured of the plague (Laius was Jocasta's husband before she married Oedipus). Hearing this, Oedipus swears he will find the murderer and banish him. The Chorus (representing the people of Thebes) suggests that Oedipus consult Teiresias, the blind prophet. Oedipus tells them that he has already sent for Teiresias. When Teiresias arrives, he seems reluctant to answer Oedipus's questions, warning him that he does not want to know the answers. Oedipus threatens him with death, and finally Teiresias tells him that Oedipus himself is the killer, and that his marriage is a sinful union. Oedipus takes this as an insult and jumps to the conclusion that Creon paid Teiresias to say these things. Furious, Oedipus dismisses him, and Teiresias goes, repeating as he does, that Laius's killer is right here before him - a man who is his father's killer and his mother's husband, a man who came seeing but will leave in blindness. Creon enters, asking the people around him if it is true that Oedipus slanderously accused him. The Chorus tries to mediate, but Oedipus appears and charges Creon with treason. Jocasta and the Chorus beg......

Words: 3537 - Pages: 15

The Burial of Count Orgaz

...“The Burial of Count Orgaz” analysis The Burial of Count Orgaz is a painting by famous renaissance artist El Greco. The painting is sixteen by eleven feet and was drawn with oil on canvas. The painting depicts a burial scene of Count Orgaz and a heaven scene with Christ above them. This painting is the most intriguing for El Greco’s use of two focal points. In El Greco’s career The Burial of Count Orgaz is widely accepted as his greatest work. In describing the painting itself it is divided into two sections, one being a burial scene of Count Orgaz in the lower half portion of the artwork, and a scene of heaven with Christ and the saints swirling overhead among thin silky clouds. The two distinct sections of this artwork give the painting two focal points, which the eyes are drawn towards. The section of the artwork depicting heaven has Christ as a focal point, he is centered at the very top of the painting with virtually every figure around him looking up with some motioning towards him. Christ is dressed in white robe, and the figures surrounding Christ vary from Saints to musicians, angles, multitudes of followers, and the Virgin Mary. The figures all seem to be swirling among silky clouds around Christ which gives each figure a distinct position and proportion in the painting, some closer up and distinctive, other more further away and faded. The burial scene directly below the heavens has the Count Orgaz as the focal point and he is positioned near the lowest part...

Words: 1226 - Pages: 5

Burial Rites Landscape and Weather

...How does Hannah Kent make the landscape and weather an integral part of the novel? Amidst the journey of the last woman executed in Iceland is the ‘nature [that] is watchful of all of us.’ Kent parallels the protagonist Agnes’ story alongside the force of the harsh Icelandic climate and country that ‘is as awake as you and I’ and often determines key events in the novel. The ominous foreshadowing of death represented in elements of the landscape highlights how the country is an essential aspect of the novel, often adding to the dramatic effect. Agnes’ road to spiritual redemption, both religion based and personal, is greatly influenced by the natural occurrences of the country. Ultimately, the harsh Icelandic conditions impact the lives of many characters, regularly wielding its power that can determine their paths. Despite Kent’s fundamental notion of the force of the nature, it is also the individuals of higher status that have the ability to control and enforce their will on others. Kent highlights the integral nature of the landscape by using motifs to foreshadow impending events. With Agnes’ forthcoming ‘execution,’ death is regularly referred to in the novel often by the ‘ravens in the sky.’ As she arrives at Korsna, where Agnes awaits her death, she hears ‘the caw of ravens’ and as demonstrated by Kent’s simile, are ‘dark shapes like omens.’ Thus this may imply that the ‘omen’ cements the notion from the exposition that Agnes’ fate has been determined. Kent......

Words: 1126 - Pages: 5

Burial Rites

...“Knowing what a person has done, and knowing who a person is, are two different things”. How does Hannah Kent’s Burial Rites provide insight into the experience of Agnes? * * * * * * * * In Burial Rites, Hannah Kent explores the idea that behind even the most heinous of actions, there can be ambiguity; that stories are shaped by self interest, biases and ideologies of the day, which can challenge preconceived beliefs of guilt. Using excerpts from archival material, juxtaposed with a story told through multiple narrators, including first person monologues of the protagonist, Kent allows us to appreciate Agnes not just as an evil scheming murderess, but as someone with a complex history and vulnerabilities, offering a deeper understanding of her experience. The use of material from historical archives to preface the chapters of Burial Rites, creates a powerful authenticity to the story that provides a factual skeleton of Agnes, as well as insights into the way she was treated by the authorities. Kent is able to use ‘truths’, such as her literacy, intelligence and poverty, established by the Ministerial Records and inventory of her possessions, to flesh out the persona of Agnes and explore their implications in terms of her experience. They also reveal the deep love and attachment that Agnes had for Natan and her continuing grief over his loss, through her poetry in response to Poet Rosa, with lines like “do not scratch my bleeding wounds” and “my soul is......

Words: 1203 - Pages: 5

Residential Burial Sites

...Paper 1 Residential Burial Sites Residential Burial Sites Upon conducting my research, I found multiple sites that I will be referencing in my paper. The main purpose of this paper is to inform people about the residential burial methods used in Thailand and Coastal Oaxaca, Mexico. In one of the articles I found it describes residential burials by saying, “Residential burial” or “intramural burial” has often been used to denote subfloor or other types of burials within residential structures, such as those within structure walls. (Residential Burial in Global Perspective Ron L. Adams Simon Fraser University and Stacie M. King Indiana University, PG. 3) This is to give a basic idea on what will be further discussed in this paper. In the article that was found, there were multiple burial sites where archeologists found remains and burial methods all over Thailand. These places in Thailand where they found these residential burial sites are, “The mortuary remains from most of these low mound sites including Ban Kao (Sørensen 1967), Non Nok Tha (Bayard 1984, 1996–97), Ban Na Di (Higham and Kijngam 1984a, 1984b, 1984c), Khok Phanom Di (Higham and Thosarat 1994:23), Nong Nor (Higham and Thosarat 1998), Ban Wang Hai (Pautreau et al. 2001), Ban Lum Khao (Higham and O’Reilly 2004:301), Noen U-Loke (Talbot 2007:305), and Ban Non Wat (Higham 2008, 2009a; Higham and Thosarat 2006), have all been discussed explicitly in terms of being “cemeteries” (Residential Burial and the......

Words: 1212 - Pages: 5

Egyptian Burial

...When it comes to ancient burial practices a huge trendsetter would be the ancient Egyptians and there unique and very elaborate tombs. Egyptians had the belief that these tombs were made to protect the bodies and secure the immortality after death. The design of these tomb structures like pyramids and mastabas had a main goal of preserving each corpse of the deceased and the Egyptians in return though this would keep their souls in what they called the “afterlife”, a place you go after you die In the early period, Egyptians had buried much simpler graves in the stranded deserts. Overtime these leaned towards the use of royal mastabas that were rectangular structures made of stone or mud bricks that kept the corpses of many Egyptian people. During the Old Kingdom, mastabas evolved and developed into rock-cut pyramids. The Pyramids of Giza, which were giant stone-cut structures, constructed from limestone, and are the most popular and evident example of pyramid tombs built during the Old Kingdom. With pyramids as massive as these it’s only fitting that they were constructed for the kings. Tombs were created out of permanent materials and the interior walls of the tombs show decoration of scenes portraying everyday life as an Egyptian along with funerary rituals. The Egyptians preserved the bodies they kept in the tombs in a process they called mummification, it was done in a variety of stages like removing all internal organs, they were able to wrap the whole body...

Words: 556 - Pages: 3

Tibetan Sky Burial Culture

...Tibetan Sky Burial Culture Brandon Andres Medicine Hat College IDST 485 – Death and Dying Susan Sverdrup-Phillips Due: March 10, 2014 Word Count = 1985 The most popular method of disposal of the dead in Tibet is a sky burial. This will seem exceedingly savage and disrespectful to many others outside this culture. A sky burial is the funeral and burial process of feeding a dismantled and cut up human corpse to vultures. If one is to fully study the country of Tibet and its peoples’ history then one can understand the reasonable logic to why this form of burial is not savage or disrespectful to a being. This Sky Burial tradition is still the most popular and desired way that Tibetans are buried after their death due to their enlightened beliefs. Firstly, this essay will state and discuss the historical reasons why sky burials would have started and became prevalent in Tibet. Second, this will look at the process and impacts of performing a Sky Burial. Lastly, it will discuss the debates of having a ceremonial sky burials in Tibet. In North American culture the most common and traditional method are to use caskets and accompany it by some type of ritual or ceremony or else the most common alternative to disposing of human remains is cremation (Basmajian and Coutts 2010:309-310) This method in North America is so common to hide the physical corpse from others and bury or cremate it that when people are presented with a sky burial one might think the “profession......

Words: 2248 - Pages: 9

Paper

...based off an unfortunate prophecy that took place in Thebes. One day a prophet came to Oedipus’s parents, Iocaste and Laios and told them a prophecy that one day their son was going to kill his father and marry his mother so they sent him away for adoption. Oedipus’s parents did this in order to to stop the prophecy from coming true. Their plan fails and the prophecy soon comes true.Oedipus and Iocaste have four children together which they named Antigone,Ismene, Polyneices, and Eteocles. When Oedipus finds out that he married his mother and killed his father he blinds himself and leaves Thebes. After Oedipus left , his two sons Polyneices and Eteocles are next in line for being king. When polyneices betrayed Thebes both brothers fight in a battle for the throne and both die in the process. The throne was then taken by their uncle Creon who was a powerful ruler. Creon was an unfair ruler because he gave Eteocles a proper burial with military honors, but said that no one should bury Polyneices because of the betrayal he did to his people and that he should be left out for all the stray dogs and birds. Creon thought that Polyneices was a trader and not worth the burial and that's what the gods wanted as well as what himself . Antigone the sister of both the brothers was not happy of the decision the king Creon made. She believed that both her brother fought with equality and that they both deserve proper burial. She tries to convince her sister Ismene to help her......

Words: 576 - Pages: 3