Sane or Insane

In: Social Issues

Submitted By cspr24
Words 837
Pages 4
Pierce 1
Jason Pierce
Wendy L. Eddy
English 1213-308
24 Mar 2010
Sane or Insane Albert Fish was so demented that he stuck alcohol soaked cotton balls into his anus after setting them on fire. He was also found with twenty nine needles stuck in his body between his anus and his scrotum. Fish was also found guilty of the killings of fifteen little boys and mutilating one hundred others. He said that God told him to do it. The doctors said that he suffered from a religious psychosis (Rawlins). Some people seem to get away with these kinds of heinous crimes because of insanity and others, who really have mental problems, get locked away in prison and forgotten about. The definition of insanity is “the mental illness of such a severe nature that a person cannot distinguish fantasy from reality, cannot conduct his/her affairs due to psychosis, or is subject to uncontrollable impulsive behavior” (Insanity). In other words, a person may live in a fantasy world and believe that things are going on around them that really are not. Also, a person may not be able to control their urges. For instance, a person may get the urge to flip someone the middle finger that cuts them off in traffic. This would be an uncontrollable impulsive behavior. Many serial killers use this line of defense as a strategy to get put into a mental hospital rather than prison. Mental hospitals give prisoners less rules and more freedoms than do
Pierce 2 prisons. Some killers though, are truly insane. There is a fine line, as well as a good defense attorney, as to which side you fall on, sane or insane.
Jeffrey Dahmer committed at least seventeen murders and entered a not guilty by reason of insanity plea but was found guilty of fifteen murders and found to be sane. One might ask how Dahmer can be sane after butchering so many young men and even keeping parts of their bodies in his…...

Similar Documents

Hamlet's Madness

...faking the whole thing. The meaning for insanity on is “a permanent disorder of the mind.” Hamlet didnt have a permanent disorder of the mind he knew what he was doing and even planned the majority of the events that happened. Most of the time anyway. Having your father die is bad enough, but to have your mother marry your uncle, within a few weeks of your father’s death? Then to see the ghost of your dead father. That would drive anyone a little insane, but maybe not to the extent that everyone thought Hamlet was acting. Hamlet is torn between acting sane and letting everyone else see him as insane. Throughout the story Hamlet pretends to be insane and even dies acting out this front of insanity. At first it seems as though Hamlet is just acting, but then it appears that he does truly indeed go insane. Even after he has gathered evidence against Claudius, he continues to act strangely. When he murders Polonius, thinking that he is Claudius, he does not react to his actions in the manor in which a sane person would. This act enrages Laertes who then desires to avenge his fathers death by slaughtering Hamlet. The death of Claudius by the hands of Hamlet also contributes to the dismay of Ophelia. In these ways, Hamlet's insanity contributes to the overall tragedy of the play. Hamlet is so grieved by his father's death that he begins to think of suicide. “O,tht this too too soid flesh would melt thaw and resolve itelf into a dew!” (Act 1, Scene 2, Lines......

Words: 1932 - Pages: 8

Hamlet and One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest

...Many questions have been asked if Hamlet, McMurphy and Chief Bromden are crazy or sane. Hamlet is the main character from a play by William Shakespeare called Hamlet. McMurphy and Chief are characters from a novel by Ken Kesey called One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest. There have been many scenes in the play where Hamlet might seams crazy but without a doubt he is sane. Even though McMurphy do some crazy things he is definitely not crazy because he is aware of his actions and he does all these insane things just to make the Nurse Ratched mad. Chief Bromden’s character can easily be identified as sane because he knows how to stay out of trouble and from getting electric shock treatments. Hamlet says to Horatio “How strange or odd soe'er I bear myself, As I perchance hereafter shall think meet to put an antic disposition on,” (I. v. 172-174). This quote is said right after when the Ghost tells Hamlet that his uncle Claudius has murdered his father. Hamlet plans on pretending to be a crazy so he can get revenge on Claudius. He also mentions to Horatio that to keep this to himself as a secret. This is perfect quote to proof Hamlet is not crazy and puts on an act as a madman. When Hamlet talks to Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, he tells them in a way that he would be portray as a madman that he has been acting insane. “I am but mad north-north-west: when the wind is southerly I know a hawk from a handsaw.” (II. ii. 132-133). He also let them know that their true reason for......

Words: 766 - Pages: 4

Philosophy Sociology Psychology (Psp)

...Page4/5 Question 2) What do We mean when we say nobody understands Insanity?.......................................................................Page6 Conclusion/References……………………………………………..Page7 Introduction In this assignment I will answer the Two questions given in class by the lecturer which are: • What is Sociological Imagination? and • What do we mean, when we say no one understands insanity? I will use help from online sources and material given in class (slide about D.L. Rosenhan, 1973, on being sane in insane places.) given by the lecturer to help me develop ideas and reach a good conclusion and understanding of the questions above. I will also analyse Sociological Imagination based on C. Wright Mills ideas, I will develop my own ideas on sociological imagination and also have a critical analysis on insanity and sanity, explaining why is difficult or almost impossible to differentiate the sane from the insane. I will also relate inanity to Sociological imagination. This assignment contains references and aconclusion. Question 1) What is Sociological Imagination? Sociological imagination, is a neologism of sociology, analysed by the American social scientist C. Wright Mills in 1959, that seeks to describe the connection process between the person's individual experience with social institutions under which they live, and their own place in the history of mankind. It is the ability to develop sociologists to analyze the......

Words: 1202 - Pages: 5

Hamlet Pleads Sane

...Hamlet Pleads Sane William Shakespeare’s play Hamlet is considered to be a great tragedy in the eyes of many. In the play, the protagonist, Hamlet, is on a quest to avenge the death of his father. At the beginning of the play, Hamlet is upset that his mother married his uncle, Claudius, only two months after his father’s death. As the story progresses, Hamlet is confronted by King Hamlet’s ghost. The ghost informs Hamlet that he was murdered by Claudius. When the ghost asks Hamlet to seek revenge for his murder, Hamlet takes on the task whole-heartedly. Hamlet’s actions, in the first half of the play, are rooted in revenge and anger, not madness. I can prove he is not crazy and acts as a normal human, out of curiosity. Hamlet’s first soliloquy begins by him suggesting, “Oh,that this too, too-solid flesh would melt, Thaw, and resolve itself into a dew! Or that the Everlasting had not fix’d His canon 'gainst self-slaughter!”(Shakespeare 1.2.129-132).This excerpt clearly highlights Hamlet’s thoughts regarding his mother’s recent nuptials. It only took Gertrude two months after the death of King Hamlet to marry Claudius. This abrupt marriage causes Hamlet to suspect that something might have been taking place between the two before his father’s death. Hamlet reacts as any logical or sane individual who finds himself in the same situation. Hamlet’s anger towards the hasty marriage between Claudius and Gertrude is a logical reaction that any sane individual has; thus......

Words: 644 - Pages: 3


...Summary on "On Being Sane in Insane Places" by D. L. Rosenhan D.L. Rosenhan was an American psuchologist, he was best known for the rosenhan experiment and study of challenging the validity of psychology diagnosis. He was a leading expert on psychology and law. In 1973 he published "On being sane in insane places," one of the most vividly read articles in the field of psychology. The article details the Rosenhan experiment. "On being Sane in insane places" was an experiment done to test the validity of psychiatric diagnosis. It tested a variety of people. It used (3 women, and 5 males a psychology graduate student in his 20s, three psychologists, a paediatrician, a psychiatrist, a painterm and a housewife) "pseudopatients" who faked hallusinations to attempt to get into 12 different psyc hospital in 5 different states across the U.S. They scheduled appointment and showed up complaining of hearing voices. They stated they didn't know the voice but it was the same sex as them. They also said that the voice was saying "empty", "hollow", and "thud". The pseudo patients gave fake names and job information to protect their true identites, but all other information was true. Such as life expirences, relationships, and so forth. They were all admitted and diagnosed with schizaphrenia except for one. After admission they told staff they were fine and were still forced to take antipsychotic drugs. They discharged from each hospital after 7-52 days,but only after accepting their......

Words: 635 - Pages: 3

Abnormal Behavior

...supports Rosenhan’s beliefs, that psychiatrists cannot be reliable in telling the differences between the sane and mentally insane. In this study all of the Pseudopatients arrived at the mental hospitals complaining about hearing voices. The voice, that they heard was unfamiliar and the same sex as themselves. Words like ‘empty’, ‘hollow’, ‘thud’ were used to raise apprehensions about how worthless their life where. Other details they gave were real general ups and downs in life. All but one was admitted and diagnosis with schizophrenia. After they were admitted to the psychiatric ward, the Pseudopatients stopped simulating any symptoms of abnormality. Inside the psychiatric ward Pseudopatients felt invisible and depressed. None of the staff at any of the 12 different hospitals in five different states in the USA noticed that all of the Pseudopatients stopped showing any symptoms of abnormality. I think behaviors from patients inside the psychiatric ward sometimes get misinterpreted by staff and psychiatrists. Their normal behaviors were often seen as part of their supposed illness. Some of the other patients suspect the Pseudopatients to be sain and even expressed their suspicions yelling “You’re not crazy”, “You’re a journalist”, or “a professor”. The patients were more reliably then the psychiatrists on telling the difference between people who are sane and those who are insane. All eight Pseudopatients were eventually discharged with the same diagnosis of......

Words: 382 - Pages: 2

On Being Sane in Insane Places

...1 On Being Sane in Insane Places Rosenhan’s study, “On Being Sane in Insane Places” caused a lot of controversy in the field of psychiatry. Rosenhan and eight other participants agreed to attempt to have themselves admitted into a psychiatric hospital on the assumption that they were hearing a voice. As Rosenham stated, the voice they were hearing would say something along the lines of, “I am hearing a voice. It is saying thud (page 65).” Rosenhan wanted to see if people claiming to hear voices would be admitted into a psychiatric hospital and labeled with some kind of mental illness or if maybe they would be prescribed medication that would alter their state of mind. Rosenhan was, without a second guess, admitted. Once he was inside, he went back to being normal. At one point he even stated to the doctor, “You know, the voice isn’t bothering me anymore (page 67).” Rosenhan once claimed, “that diagnosis is not carried within the person, but within the context, and that any diagnostic process that lends itself so readily to massive errors of this sort cannot be a very reliable one.” Being admitted and put on medication due to hearing voices or being released on the diagnosis of being in remission is quite ridiculous. Rosenhan had validity to his claims. They were all admitted without a second thought. All were given medications, even after going back to being normal. They were all kept in the psychiatric hospitals for...

Words: 714 - Pages: 3

Taliban Are Insane

...“Taliban” are Insane The young generation of Pakistan is an asset and the future of this country. How the children and the youngsters are going to behave and act in future? This depends on the education system of the state. In Pakistan, boys of very young age are dragged into religious extremism. This extremism is more dangerous than terrorism. We can’t label any nation as a terrorist nor can we blame a specific religion for disturbing the peace around the world by extremism or terrorism. Families who cannot afford school send their children to Madrasas. Now some Madrasas are not just religion teaching institutions rather they are the brain washing factories of extremism and terrorism and the parents often do not care and do not know what their children are learning at these places. We saw that in the documentary. The government here is to be blamed because they are responsible for taking care of the institutions of both the religious and non-religious educations. The government should take strict actions against all the un-registered institutions. All the syllabus of both the madrasas and other education systems should be under the control of the government. The government should design the syllabus in such a way that conveys the true message of Islam, which is peace. Secondly the media is to be blamed here as well because media is the one who creates an image of a society. Whether positive or negative, although things have changed now and Pakistan is a lot safer and......

Words: 538 - Pages: 3

Crj 311 Week 2 Journal Sane

...WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE To purchase this visit following link: Contact us at: SUPPORT@ACTIVITYMODE.COM CRJ 311 WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE CRJ 311 WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE To purchase this visit following link: Contact us at: SUPPORT@ACTIVITYMODE.COM CRJ 311 WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE CRJ 311 WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE To purchase this visit following link: Contact us at: SUPPORT@ACTIVITYMODE.COM CRJ 311 WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE CRJ 311 WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE To purchase this visit following link: Contact us at: SUPPORT@ACTIVITYMODE.COM CRJ 311 WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE CRJ 311 WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE To purchase this visit following link: Contact us at: SUPPORT@ACTIVITYMODE.COM CRJ 311 WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE CRJ 311 WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE To purchase this visit following link: Contact us at: SUPPORT@ACTIVITYMODE.COM CRJ 311 WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE CRJ 311 WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE To purchase this visit following link: Contact us at: SUPPORT@ACTIVITYMODE.COM CRJ 311 WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE CRJ 311 WEEK 2 JOURNAL SANE To purchase......

Words: 455 - Pages: 2


...penalty? This was the case with Charles Laverne Singleton Argument Charles Laverne Singleton was found guilty for the murder of a grocery clerk in 1979 and was sentenced to death. While awaiting the death penalty, Singleton’s mental capacity began to deteriorate. Can someone be treated for incompetency then be put to death? This was the argument that stood out in the Singleton’s case. The public had mixed feelings about this case but the federal appeals court made their decision on February 11, 2003. “The federal appeals court ruled that officials in Arkansas can force a prisoner on death row to take antipsychotic medication to make him sane enough to execute because of the Supreme Court decision that prohibits the execution of the insane” (Liptak 2003). Authorities are allowed to give antipsychotic medication to insane death row prisoners so they are able to know and understand that the bad decisions they have made has now resulted in their death. This decision will indeed pave the way for others that are in the same situation as Singleton. My Position When someone is born into this world, it is easy to make assumptions that “this baby will be a doctor, or this baby will be a famous actress.” We hardly hear the assumptions such as “this baby will be a murderer or a rapist.” This is due to the fact that babies are seen as angelic and innocent human beings. This would all change when that baby grows up and begins making decisions. The baby’s......

Words: 770 - Pages: 4


...On Being Sane in Insane Places Zehra Morgan 21737604 February 17, 2016 Introduction to Sociology 125 1. Immediately after admission, the pseudo patients acted normally (asymptomatic) while discreetly taking notes for the experiment.  The pseudo patients acted normally and told staff that they felt fine and had no longer experienced any additional hallucinations. All were forced to admit to having a mental illness and agree to take antipsychotic drugs as a condition of their release. The average time that the patients spent in the hospital was 19 days. All but one was diagnosed with schizophrenia "in remission" before their release. The second part of his study involved an offended hospital administration challenging Rosenhan to send pseudo patients to its facility, which its staff would then detect. Rosenhan agreed and in the following weeks out of 193 new patients the staff identified 41 as potential pseudo patients, with 19 of these receiving suspicions from at least one psychiatrist and one other staff member. 2. In 1973, psychiatrists were embarrassingly bad at distinguishing the mentally ill from the normal.  Today, psychopathology is still very subjective and arguably as much of an art as it is a science, with questionable criteria as to what is considered a mental "illness" or not. Despite constantly and openly taking extensive notes on the behavior of the staff and other patients, none of the pseudo patients were identified as impostors by the hospital......

Words: 961 - Pages: 4


...adversity and is destined to murder the individual who killed his father. Hamlet is a character who although his actions and emotions may be one of an insane person, in the beginning of the book it is clear that Hamlet decides to fake madness in order for his plan to succeed in killing Claudius. Hamlet is sane because throughout the play he only acts crazy in front of certain people, to others he acts properly and displays proper prince like behavior who is able to cope with them without sounding crazy, and even after everything that has been going on in his life he is able to take revenge by killing his father's murderer. In the play Hamlet by William Shakespeare Hamlet is sane but acts insane to fulfill his destiny of getting vengeance on his father's murderer. Hamlet throughout the play seems insane but in reality it is only an act to achieve his goal of killing his father's murderer. Hamlet chooses to go mad so he has an advantage over his opponent and since he is the Prince of Denmark cert... ... middle of paper ... individual's, if an individual was crazy they would not be thinking everything through and if someone were crazy they would definitely not have the capabilities of outsmarting someone, like how Hamlet outsmarted Claudius. All these reasons and much more are why Hamlet is not insane, he is as sane of an individual as any other, but unlike others he had to go through a lot of emotional pain and a sense of abandonment to reach a successful......

Words: 280 - Pages: 2

The Case for Sanity

...confession of sorts by Montresor. The most prominent question of all, is Montresor insane? Could it be possible to murder someone over a verbal insult and still be in one’s right mind? One could conclude after multiple reads and after gaining a better understanding of the irony in the story that a person in their right mind(sane), but with ill intentions, as in the case of Montresor, would be able to plan such a brutal crime. One must take into consideration, what is sanity? As defined by Merriam-Webster “sanity is the quality or state of being sane; especially: soundness or health of mind,” (“sanity”). With that definition in mind, it is important to consider what determines the soundness or health of mind? In today’s society those determinations are made through the use of ethics and morals. In general, a person’s sanity is questioned when others believe someone has done something ridiculous/extreme and out of the ordinary, or during trials for crimes. During trials for crimes, it would be efficient to say that a person has done something extremely ridiculous and out of the ordinary for most people, like robbing or murdering someone. For all intents and purposes, it could be argued that Montresor could be insane. To hold onto a grudge for such a long time over an insult, then to plan, what, in the end, is the perfect murder, could also be deemed as sane. However, would a person who is deemed sane, be able to put that much thought into a step by step murder, and feel......

Words: 1420 - Pages: 6

A Sane Killer

...A Reasonably Sane Killer Jeffrey Lionel Dahmer was born may 21st 1960, in West Allis, Wisconsin. He was the son of Joyce Annette and Lionel Herbert Dahmer, and an older brother to David Dahmer. By all accounts he was born into a seemingly normal family, in a middle class white neighborhood. He attended and completed Revere High School, and then attended Ohio State University for a short period of time, but was asked to leave due to his drinking habits. Dahmer underwent Hernia surgery when he was eight years old, and it is said to have changed his personality from that point on. Growing up, Dahmer realized at a young age his fascination with dead creatures. He would patrol his neighborhood for dead animals and then bring them back to his home or the woods and dissect them. Although Dahmer did not torture or kill animals, he had pets of his own at home; he was interested in seeing what was inside of them. At the age of thirteen, Dahmer also had the realization that he was homosexual, causing him major confusion, and sexual frustration. After the age of thirteen he began to distance himself from reality more and more. He suffered from being the victim of bullying all through his school years, due to his strange uncommunicative personality. He was also suffering from loneliness and rejection from his peers and family. Dahmer severely lacked social skills in his teenage and childhood years. At this point in his life he was starting to have very impulsive fantasies......

Words: 1660 - Pages: 7

A Society Defines Conformity

...The statement “a society defines ‘conformity’ as ‘that which is sane’” from Literature: The Human Experience can be analyzed through Henrick Ibsen’s drama A Doll’s House. This play allows the audience to examine the life of a woman under pressure to conform to a society’s standards, of whose manipulation she is unaware. As her eyes are opened to the dehumanization and self-serving nature of her friends and family, Nora finds that what she thought to be “sane” all along, really is quite the opposite. Webster’s Dictionary defines “conformity” as “action in accordance with some specified standard or authority.” This definition validates that those around Nora dictated her way of living. Torvald Helmer, Nora’s husband, views her as a child, or incapable of independent or intelligent thought which causes Nora to not delve into deeper issues and to “grow” into an adult. Toward the end of the play, Nora says to Torvald, “I was your little skylark, your doll, which you would in future, treat with doubly care, because it was so brittle and fragile.” Torvald never saw her as anything more than a play-thing, a doll, or someone that lacked knowledge or depth. It is as if society has ingrained in Torvald that women are to be treated as children and as though they cannot think for themselves. The term sane, as defined by Webster’s Dictionary, means “mentally sound, able to anticipate and appraise the effect of one’s actions.” In Nora, Ibsen creates a woman who is mentally sound......

Words: 652 - Pages: 3