Ethical Decision Making Is the Reality That There Is Almost Always a Greater Need for Something Than There Is a Supply to Meet the Need.

In: English and Literature

Submitted By evie101
Words 396
Pages 2
Scenario
Scenario Summary

One of the great and ongoing situations that calls for ethical decision making is the reality that there is almost always a greater need for something than there is a supply to meet the need.

For our assignment and scenario, the need is the life-and-death situation of the need for transplantable organs and the rather small and transitory supply. Hard decisions need to be made, and there is little time to think things through. These are emergency situations.

Transplantable organs become available on short notice – usually because a donor has died for reasons unrelated to the organ. They need to be removed and transplanted very quickly, because they only remain fresh for a limited period. And there is the whole complicated issue of tissue type matching. There is also an ongoing concern about how long recipients can wait.

KEY PLAYERS
Roles
Back to Top
Choices and Consequences

Review the roles for this scenario before proceeding to the activity.

YOU DECIDE
Activity

Your assignment is to make the decision using utilitarian ethics as this week’s classwork and discussions have brought you to that skill and then to write it up in the form of a Memorandum for the hospital records. Remember that this record could be reviewed by the Peer Review Committee or the Hospital Trustees at a later date.

This is Utilitarian Week in our course. Employ what you have learned from J. S. Mill and Utilitarianism this week AND one other of our course’s ethicists of your choice from week 1.

The Memorandum should be at 2 double-spaced pages, maximum of 3 pages, in a memorandum form ready to become an official item of record.

Category % Description
Content 50% Quality of Memorandum content
Analysis 35% Employs what you have learned from J. S. Mill and Utilitarianism this week AND one other of our course’s ethicists of your…...

Similar Documents

Ethical Decision Making

...Ethical Decision Making in the Military Ethical Decision Making in the Military Lawren John Doyle Business Ethics 323 Professor Smith July 25, 2012 Thesis The American public is bombarded with ethics violations on all levels, including corporate scandals, university cover-ups, and wasteful government spending.   Ethical leaders are becoming important  now more than ever.  If basic, common sense ethics had been exercised, the economy would not be in the situation it is in today.   The military has been known for creating exceptional leaders, but just like any other organization, there is always room for improvement.  In the military, it is extremely important to make ethical decisions.  Leaders are entrusted with hard-earned taxpayer dollars and the lives of America’s most valuable asset, people.  This paper focuses on the importance of making sound ethical decisions.  Leaders operating overseas must use ethics as a cornerstone in their decision making process to ensure commanders are able to maximize resources and to promote a culture of integrity for soldiers to emulate when they become leaders. During a recent deployment, our Task Force conducted a series of Joint Combined Exercise Training blocks to build relationships with foreign allies.  One of the well-respected platoon leaders began writing inaccurate reports that embellished the positive points and left out the negative points to demonstrate his superior management skills.  When others in the team were asked......

Words: 1565 - Pages: 7

Ethical Decision-Making in the Military Decision-Making Process

...Ethical Decision-Making in the Military Decision-Making Process Contribution to the JSCOPE 2000 Conference “Moral Considerations in Military Decision Making”. Dr. D. (Desiree) Verweij Lieutenant Colonel G.A.A.M. (Gérard) Cloïn (drs.) Major E.C. (Erhan) Tanercan MED (drs.) E-mail: ilmo@army.disp.mindef.nl Tel: +31 76 527 46 53 begin_of_the_skype_highlighting +31 76 527 46 53 end_of_the_skype_highlighting Introduction A great deal has changed in the Royal Netherlands Army (RNLA) in recent years. Not only has the task of the RNLA changed, but so has its composition. To begin with the first aspect: the task of the RNLA and that of the armed forces as a whole has been extended. This means that operations outside the Netherlands in all manner of international frameworks, such as the UN and NATO, have become the rule rather than the exception. The composition of the RNLA and of the armed forces has also changed. We no longer have conscripts in our army; we have all-volunteer forces, forces that wish to reflect society on a number of important counts. One of the significant consequences of the changes in respect of the new task and composition of the armed forces is the confrontation with different cultures and with different and new values and standards. To ensure that military personnel are able to deal with this situation in a professional manner, education in ethics is extremely important. This article elaborates on...

Words: 5155 - Pages: 21

Ethical Decision Making and Ethical Leadership

...ETHICAL DECISION MAKING AND ETHICAL LEADERSHIP To improve ethical decision making in business, one must first understand how individuals make ethical decisions in an organizational environment. Too often it is assumed that individuals in organizations make ethical decisions in the same way that they make ethical decisions at home, in their family, or in their personal lives. Within the context of an organizational work group, however, few individuals have the freedom to decide ethical issues independent of organizational pressures. ETHICAL – ISSUE INTENSITY The first step in ethical decision making is to recognize that an ethical issue requires an individual or work group to choose among several actions that various stakeholders inside or outside the firm will ultimately evaluate as right or wrong. Ethical issue intensity, then, can be defined as the relevance or importance of an ethical issue in the eyes of the individual, work group, and/or organization. it is personal and temporal in character to accommodate values, beliefs, needs, perceptions, the special characteristics of the situation, and the personal pressure prevailing at a particular place and time. Ethical – issue intensity reflects the ethical sensitivity of the individual or work group that faces the ethical decision – making process. Research suggest that individuals are subject to six “spheres of influence” when confronted with ethical choices – the workplace, family, religion, legal system,......

Words: 3754 - Pages: 16

Ethical Decision Making

...about an ethical decision-making process it seems logical to think about how decisions in general are made by people. Decisions can be made on a programmed or nonprogrammed basis. Programmed decisions assume that the decision-maker already dealt with similar decisions before which now causes automatic reactions. Nonprogrammed decisions are more complex because they deal with new situations. Both kinds of decisions include a decision-making process that follows various steps until it reaches the final decision. No matter what kind of decision is made, somebody must play the important role of identifying a problem and, if applicable, recognizing similar situations already occurred before. Since those steps require a certain knowledge that only experts have, the responsibility will mostly likely lie with the leader of a team, project or the whole company. Even more important is the role of a leader in ethical decision making. The goal of a leader should be to meet the needs of stockholders, customers, employees, the environment, and other stakeholders. Ethics is an essential factor in business and of successful leadership and therefore ethics and leadership should go hand in hand. Successful leaders must be aware of several organizational and individual values. The foundation is, as so often, a good character. But since there is a connection between the employees’ own values and those of their workplace, a leader must be able to use these values in ethical decision......

Words: 571 - Pages: 3

Making Effective and Ethical Decisions

...Making Effective and Ethical Decisions Rose Johnson MGT400_M4_A2 Devry University April 15, 2013 Making Effective and Ethical Decisions Making ethical decisions requires the ability to make distinctions between competing choices. “Ethical decisions are guided by the underlying values of the individual. Values are principles of conduct such as caring, being honest, showing loyalty, acting with integrity, respecting others, and being a responsible citizen (Bateman, 2009. p.168)”. When conversing concerns of ethical conduct in the office employees must realize that culture plays a massive part on how an individual creates ethical decision. Ethical problems in the office may contribute from incorrect employees’ conduct, which includes stock trading, sexual harassment, account fraud, and participation in conflicts of interest. To accomplish the desires of these strategies, the businesses will create a written principles of ethical behaviors for implementing these strategies, allocate accountability to executive leaders to confirm that the policy is functioning as planned, dismiss any person who disrupts the values from practicing management titles, offer training in ethics to workers, observe compliance, provide employees compensation for obeying the policies and reply with penalties if illegal behavior comes to surface (Healthfield, 2013). The company must consider ethics training in order to take advantage of the ethic policies in place. The......

Words: 1385 - Pages: 6

Ethical Decision Making

...Ethical Decision Making  Ethics are principles that define behavior as fair and proper and they are concerned with how a moral person should behave when it comes to making an ethical decision (Josephson Institute of Ethics, 2002). Evaluating and deciding among competing options is often key in making a fair choice since principles do not always dictate a single "moral" course of action.  The decision of whether to lay off workers to enhance profits or to cut corners on quality to meet a deadline are examples of some choices regarding ethics business owners may face (Poznak Law Firm, 2003). The use of extremely low-wage foreign workers, like in the Nike organization case, is a current concern and the subject is a complex one.  There are many valid differences of opinion regarding what constitutes ethical behavior and how ethical decisions should be made and the subject is a complex one (Poznak Law Firm, 2003). There are always pros and cons involved with any choice and the decision itself can be quite time consuming. When it comes to deciding whether or not to use cheap labor to cut costs, businesses must examine the ethics behind their decision-making processes.  Four approaches that business owners commonly use to analyze ethical dilemmas are the utilitarian approach, which focuses on taking the action that will result in the greatest good for the greatest number of people; the moral rights approach, which is concerned with moral principles, regardless of the......

Words: 1178 - Pages: 5

Ethical Decision Making

...520 November 16, 2011 Strayer University-Allentown Campus Alan Mulally, CEO, Ford Motor Company 1.         Discuss the role of leadership and how it can impact organizational performance. Answer: Leadership is the process of developing ideas and visions, living by values that support those ideas and that vision, influencing others to embrace them in their own behaviors, and making hard decisions about human and other resources (Hellriegel & Slocum, 2011, p. 290). Whereas according to Richard et al. (2009), organizational performance comprises the actual output or results of an organization as measured against its intended goals and objectives. Effective leadership is a personal role that requires the blending of motivational, strategic and management skills to align focus, energy and drive while creating a culture that encourages individual thinking and attainment. For a leadership to impact organizational performance positively, said leadership has to posses the four leadership traits of intelligence-successful leaders tend to have somewhat higher intelligence than their subordinates; maturity and breadth-successful leaders tend to be emotionally mature and have a broad range of interests; achievement drive-successful leaders are result oriented; when they achieve one goal, they seek another and integrity-successful leaders, over the long term, usually have integrity. A leadership that possesses the above mentioned characteristics is clear, concise,......

Words: 1835 - Pages: 8

Ethical Decision Making

...Ethical Decision Making Paper Michael D. Love PSYCH 545 Sept 10th, 2012 Erica Wansel, Psy. D. Ethical Decision Making Paper Introduction The development of ethical reasoning abilities is very important for both living an ethical life and creating an ethical world. This paper will attempt to examine the foundations of ethical reasoning. It will also to introduce some intellectual tools that can be used to gain the skills necessary for reasoning through ethical issues and problems in an insightful manner. Education is considered the moral enterprise that supports our values, beliefs and cultural norms of our society. It is important in building the character of our society and the persons involved in this are not only diverse in nature but also possess greater significance in terms of deciding the overall contents of the education system of our nation. Within this context, ethics are therefore considered as one of the prime concerns for all the stakeholders. The following is an example of a possible ethical dilemma in the psychological academic arena. “As the result of a colleague’s sudden serious illness, a clinical psychologist is asked to teach a psychological course, which is definitely outside his area of expertise. The course begins in one week. The department chair recognizes that the psychologist is not competent in this area, but he is as qualified as anyone else in the department and is the only person whose schedule can accommodate the......

Words: 1476 - Pages: 6

Ethical Decision Making

...because the whistles do not meet the manufacturing standards and regulations laid down by the US government. The result of this is more extensive expenses that results from the fines put against the company and some legal costs demanded by the federal government. Another possible negative impact of this decision on the company is the potential recall and reproduction of the toys by the company. If the shipped toys are recalled and reproduced, the company will end up incurring a lot of costs. The costs are transporting the toys to and from the school and the cost of reproducing new ones. The overall result is ruining the image of the company and losses. The most important issue to note from this decision is that it is totally unethical. Subjecting children to such harmful substances implies that the company is irresponsible and is not adhering to ethical practices. Another possible solution to the whistle problem is to transport the products to a different country where the products meet the standards required in that country. This is because different countries across the world have different manufacturing standards and regulations. By doing so, the company will not experience any financial loss. The money raised from selling the products in another country will be now used to produce products that meet the requirements of the federal government and sell them to South America though there will be a delay. However, the decision will have a......

Words: 2373 - Pages: 10

Ethical Decision Making

...Ethical Decision Making Click Link Below To Buy: http://hwcampus.com/shop/ethical-decision-making/ Introduction Just as nursing applies a systematic process for evaluating the condition of a given population to determine an appropriate intervention, health care providers must also utilize a systematic process to assess the nature of an ethical dilemma to determine a reasonable solution. Ethical decisions are reasoned choices based on: • The dilemma itself. • The principles in conflict. • The people involved. • The outcome of the proposed action. • The ethical reasoning process selected. Ethical Decision Making It is helpful to use a decision-making model for ethical dilemmas in order to guide one's decision making from an objective, cognitive perspective, rather than a purely affective or emotional perspective. Uustal (1993) proposed the following steps to guide one's ethical decision making. Uustal's model not only follows the nursing process, but also includes values clarification when applying an ethical decision-making model. Step 1: Identify the problem. Ask: • Who are people involved in the dilemma? • How are they related or interrelated? • What is involved in the situation? After answering the above questions, identify the ethical dilemma and make a concise statement of the problem. Then, state the conflict in values. Step 2: State your values and ethical position related......

Words: 1120 - Pages: 5

Ethical Decision Making

...Through the phenomenographic, contextual analysis twelve different categories of leadership conceptions are generated that describe the qualitatively different ways in which the managers experienced leadership. The relationships between the conception categories are further analyzed and five categories that reveal the central themes of leadership in the small enterprise are generated. By utilizing a novel methodology in examining leadership in a small enterprise this study contributes an alternative perspective to leadership compared to the mainstream leadership research and produces a tentative, conceptual model of leadership in a small enterprise. The study raises concerns about the taken for granted conceptions of leadership as something good and indispensable and their power related implications in organizations; particularly in small, owner-run enterprises, where employees are dependent on the owner-manager. The practical contribution of the study is associated with such issues as consciousness about the social construction of leadership and leadership ideals, their interpretation and utilization in the everyday life in organizations and their implications to organizations and organizational members. Suggestions for meeting leadership expectations and developing participatory approach to leadership in small enterprises are provided. Keywords leadership, management, small enterprises, entrepreneurship, phenomenography ISBN......

Words: 100514 - Pages: 403

Supply Needs

...Supply Needs INF 336 Prof. Beverly Williams February 27, 2012 Supply Needs All companies have some type of supply need and must identify the specifications of the needs to be efficient. Supply strategies are best aligned with corporate strategies when requirements and procurability are determined, risks assessed, and suppliers are identified. Supply needs and specifications, early supplier involvement, and strategic requirements will be discussed in this paper. It is preferable to separate need identification and defining commercial equivalents into two separate stages because a company must first know what it needs and why it is needed. The type or category of need should then be determined so it is known exactly what is desired to fulfill the need. There is normally more than one way or option to satisfy a need, so the “why” helps determine how it must be produced. It must also be determined if the need is repetitive or nonrepetitive. This will determine how the product or service is purchased and through what source. A repetitive need may require a sample or trial run to ensure that the need can be met consistently on more than one occasion. Once the need is identified, it can then be converted into a commercial equivalent so the supplier can comprehend the specifications required. Separating the two stages helps identify suppliers with lower costs, higher quality, or cutting-edge technology. Without the separation, value opportunities may be......

Words: 836 - Pages: 4

Business Ethical Decision Making

...Introduction Ethical behavior is generally expected to be conducted within a business by its managers and employees. When business ethics is spoken by business people of it usually means one of three things (1) avoid breaking the criminal law in one’s work-related activity; (2) avoid action that may result in civil law suits against the company; (3) avoid actions that are bad for the company image (Erwin 2011). . Ethical issues in business will occur but can be solved and avoided in many cases that can help a company continue to be successful. Using an ethical decision making process will guide companies and its employees in the right direction to success and respect within the communities they serve. Most people involved in business whether functioning as a small business owner, employee, or chief executive officer of a multination company eventually face ethical or moral dilemmas in the workplace. Such dilemmas are usually complex, for they force the person making the decision to weigh the benefits that various business decisions impart on individuals including him or herself and groups with the negative repercussion that those same decisions usually have on other individuals or groups. What is Ethics? Business ethics is a subject that can be difficult to define. Any discussion of business ethics is a subjective one, for everyone brings different concepts of ethical behavior to the table. These moral standards are shaped by all sorts of things, from home environment......

Words: 2343 - Pages: 10

Understanding the Dilemman of Ethical Decision Making

...Understanding the Dilemma of Ethical Decision Making Understanding ethics and utilizing ethical business practices are key to the success in modern business. Traditional business organizations must take into consideration many more aspects of business today, than in the past when the focus was primarily on profits and making money for the shareholders. These ethical principles also influence non-profit and government organizations as well, taking into account the same ethical considerations that for profit organizations deal with. The modern concept of ethical organizations takes into account many issues, some of which include: • corporate social responsibility • the triple bottom line (economic, social and environmental) • ethical management and leadership • globalization • sustainability This list is not all inclusive. Ethics and ethical behaviors cover a wide range of factors and situations. Throughout the world there are many different definitions. With cultural, regional and society based interpretations of the concept. As such there are no world wide set of rules and no set standards of what is ethical. With the growing importance of ethics in the modern world, the fact that there are no set rules is fascinating. This begs the question, what is ethical? To understand this concept we must look deeper than the common definition of what an ethical organization is. There are so many factors that influence and affect an organizations ability...

Words: 6423 - Pages: 26

Model for Ethical Decision Making in Business

...J Bus Ethics (2011) 104:311–323 DOI 10.1007/s10551-011-0910-1 A Model for Ethical Decision Making in Business: Reasoning, Intuition, and Rational Moral Principles Jaana Woiceshyn Received: 11 February 2011 / Accepted: 16 May 2011 / Published online: 28 May 2011 Ó Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011 Abstract How do business leaders make ethical decisions? Given the significant and wide-spread impact of business people’s decisions on multiple constituents (e.g., customers, employees, shareholders, competitors, and suppliers), how they make decisions matters. Unethical decisions harm the decision makers themselves as well as others, whereas ethical decisions have the opposite effect. Based on data from a study on strategic decision making by 16 effective chief executive officers (and three not-soeffective ones as contrast), I propose a model for ethical decision making in business in which reasoning (conscious processing) and intuition (subconscious processing) interact through forming, recalling, and applying moral principles necessary for long-term success in business. Following the CEOs in the study, I employ a relatively new theory, rational egoism, as the substantive content of the model and argue it to be consistent with the requirements of longterm business success. Besides explaining the processes of forming and applying principles (integration by essentials and spiraling), I briefly describe rational egoism and illustrate the model with a contemporary moral...

Words: 10524 - Pages: 43