Free Essay

Economics - Market Failure

In: Business and Management

Submitted By sabrinaj123A
Words 1530
Pages 7
Environmental Market
Failure

Negative Externalities
Costs imposed on a 3rd party not involved with the consumption or production of the good (the external cost)
 Divergence between private and social cost
 MSC=MPC+MEC
 The MEC = the negative externality  The free market price is less than the optimum price leading to over consumption
 Welfare loss

Q: The market generated quantity
(where privates crosses private)
Q1: The optimum quantity
(where social crosses social)
Over consumption of Q-Q1

Unequal Distribution Effects


Citizens in poor countries are more likely to be affected by the consequences of global warming that those in rich countries



E.g. drought/flooding



They are also a lot less likely to have consumed the goods and services which caused the global warming



And a loss less able to protect them selves e.g. through insurance policies



There are inequities between those who contribute to global warming and those who suffer from it



Citizens of developed (polluting) countries pay less for their goods and services than the social costs of their production 

MSC=MPC+MEC

Government Intervention to correct
Environmental Market Failure
2 main types:
 Market based measures
Designed to modify the price mechanism using strategies such as taxes and subsidies
 Government regulation
Sometimes referred to as “Command and
Control”, designed to create incentives for firms to reduce harmful emissions, such as pollution permits which allow pollution to a certain level

Environmental Taxation
A tax placed on the producer of a good or service which is deemed to have a negative impact on the environment
 Designed to “internalise” the negative externality by increasing the private cost of production
 Tax aims to increase the private cost until it equals the social cost – to reach optimum P and Q (see dia on next slide)  Tax revenues can be used to fund spending on “clean ups” and invested in new technology that are designed to have a lower environmental impact, e.g. “clean” energy sources  Examples of environmental taxes: fuel duty, air passenger duty, landfill tax, London congestion charge

Problems with Environmental Taxation


Vary difficult to place accurate monetary values on the environment and externalities e.g. loss of habitat, so very difficult to decide on tax levels



Price elasticities of demand and supply are often not known and vary over time, meaning that it is very difficult to know how much to increase tax by to achieve a certain reduction in pollution



If the demand for a product with adverse environmental effects is inelastic, the tax may raise revenue which can be put to good use but will only reduce consumption slightly



Imposing taxes on some environmentally harmful goods such as cigarettes may be seen as regressive and worsen the distribution of income and wealth



Increasing environmental tax in one country may reduce the countries international competitiveness and encourage firms to move to countries with lower environmental taxes, which may perversely act to increase global pollution as firms take advantage of low pollution taxes in rapidly developing countries such as China and India

Pollution Regulation
 Instead of using taxation the government could regulate
 The government could set a quota they believe corresponds with the optimum level or ban certain pollution generating activities
 In the UK the Environmental Protection Act of 1989 set minimum environmental standards for industries such as waste incineration and oil refining
 Regulatory Bodies e.g. Her Majesty's Inspectorate of
Pollution inspect and fine firms that do not conform to the emission standards that have been set
 However, monitoring regulations can be difficult and expensive  In addition, regulation does not generate tax revenues that could be used to support environmental improvement schemes or compensate those who have been adversely affected by pollution

Extending Property Rights
Tragedy of the Commons
The over exploitation of natural resources that are not owned by single individuals or organisations
 Because no-one owns the air or sea no-one takes responsibility for them and they are over exploited  This is called the tragedy of the commons
 Instead of using taxation or regulation the government could create a market in property rights – the
 This internalises the negative externality through making the polluters pay and helps to limit the negative impact on the environment
 Examples: tradable pollution permits, emissions trading, carbon trading
 Popular in developed countries

Pollution Permits

What is it?
These is a permit sold to firms by the government allowing them to pollute up to a certain limit. These can be bought and sold between firms. Exceeding your legal limit will result in huge fines.
Advantages


The government can cap the total emissions allowed within a time period by limiting permissions sold



The firm’s which cause the most emissions pay the most 

Gives firms an incentive to reduce emissions



Generate revenue which can be used to further
R&D into sustainable energy – intergenerational equity (fairness)



Uses market forces to limit emissions rather than regulation Disadvantages


The system must be enforced to be effective



Requires teams of factory inspectors



Careful thought is required regarding the fines imposed if limits are exceeded

Extending Property Rights to overcome the Tragedy of the Commons
 Activity page 113
Tradable carbon pollution permits
Giving internet service providers the right to claim damages from distributors of spam for the extra cost incurred from the damage from spammers operations

Tradable quotas for water pollution
Granting property rights to local citizens who can then claim damages from offenders Tradable quotas for fishing Grant licenses for short term logging / logging quotas Environmental Market Failure
Intervention Options Summary
 Taxation
Fuel duty, air passenger duty, landfill tax, London congestion charge  Regulation
Environmental Protection Act of 1989 - minimum environmental standards for industries such as waste incineration and oil refining
Regulatory Bodies - Her Majesty's Inspectorate of
Pollution inspect and fine firms
 Extending Property Rights
Tradable pollution permits, emissions trading, carbon trading

Kyoto Protocol
 An international agreement
 Signed by government representative in
1997
 Designed to deal with climate change problems  Developed nations agreed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 5% of 1990 levels by 2012
 Allows carbon trading between industrialised countries
 Worryingly the US, who accounts for one third of all carbon emissions, withdrew from the agreement in 2001
 Rapidly developing countries such as
China and India were also not bound by the protocol, which seriously reduces the effectiveness of the agreement

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-11147780

Solar Panels
Reducing negative externalities
& thus reducing Market Failure
 Feed-in tariff
 Home owners receive 41.3p for every unit they generate, regardless of whether they use it or feed it back to the national grid
 Cost between £6k and 12k to buy and install
 Can earn home owners about £700 a year in feed back revenue plus £100 off electricity bills

 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-11149092

Key Terms
Pollution Permit: a right to emit a given volume of waste or pollution into the environment
Kyoto Protocol: an agreement made at a global summit meeting in Kyoto, Japan, to cut world carbon emissions

Past Exam Questions
Specimen
“Taxation and carbon trading can both be used to price carbon emissions” (Extract B, line 12)
Explain how a government can use taxation and carbon trading to price carbon emissions
(10 marks)

Up to 3 marks for relevant point explained:
Using taxation:
 Identifying the sources
 Placing a monetary value on the emissions
 Imposing a tax on the polluter to internalise the external cost
 Using tax to increase the price and reduce consumption
Using carbon trading:
 Imposing a ceiling or max limit on emissions for activity or firm
 Granting pollution permits
 Creating a market in which unused allowances can be traded
MAX OF 7 MARKS IF ONLY 1 IS EXPLAINED

Past Exam Questions

Jan 2011
“Imperfect information may lead to market failure”
Explain how imperfect information may result in the failure of markets for merit and demerit goods
(15 marks)

Past Exam Questions
Specimen
Using the data and your economic knowledge, discuss whether government policies that aim to reduce the rate at which climate change is occurring benefit or harm the UK.
(25 marks)
Issues and areas for discussion include:
Tax policies
Regulation
Carbon trading policies
Effective policies require international co-operation with other governments
Costs incurred in the absence of policies
Costs created by the policies themselves
Benefits experienced as a result of the policies
Social versus private costs/benefits
Government failure issues e.g. risk of too high carbon limits actually encouraging pollution

Past Exam Questions

Jan 2011
Discuss whether markets alone can be relied upon to reduce the problems of environmental pollution.
(25 marks)

Past Exam Questions
Jun 2011
“The UK’s strong reliance on landfill indicates the existence of widespread environmental market failure” (Extract B, lines 16-17)
Using the data and your economic knowledge evaluate alternative methods of correcting market failure arising from waste disposal.
(25 marks)

Past Exam Questions
Jun 2010
“It is difficult to judge whether GM crops will boost productivity to feed the world and create social benefits or cause market failure through monopoly, environmental damage and adverse side effects on human health” (Extract
B, line 38-40)
Using the data and your economic knowledge, evaluate the view that the UK Government should support the production and use of GM crops.
(25 marks)…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Market Failure

...Invisible hand, Market failure and Government intervention Invisible Hand Invisible Hand, term used in the book “The Wealth of Nations”, by classical economist Adam Smith, to characterize the idea that a guiding force leads individuals seeking their own economic self-interest to act in ways that also benefit society. A vindication of Adam Smith's intuition about the existence of an "invisible hand" bringing consistency and order to the chaos of individual actions - would be remarkable in them. Much of economic theory of the textbook variety is a celebration of the free market system. This celebration has two parts. First, the operation of the price system, in the context of competitive markets, leads to balance between the demand and supply of the different goods and services traded. In other words, flexible prices result in competitive markets clearing. Second, the market-clearing equilibrium - brought about through flexible prices and competitive markets - is a "good thing" in the sense that it is also a point of economic efficiency. In other words competitive outcomes are also efficient ones. The fact that competition leads to efficiency is known as the First Fundamental Theorem of Welfare Economics. The efficient outcome will have been brought about through parsimony in the use of information; the only things that individuals, in making their supply/demand decisions, need to know are the prices of the different commodities. Furthermore, since the efficient outcome...

Words: 1526 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Market for R&D Failures

...Mike Rondesko, KaChun Fung, Daniel Lozano, Jose Romero Professor Pe’er Final Essay 18 December 2012 Market for Trading R&D failures Advancing ones knowledge based on past failures is vital towards furthering intellectual development. Without understanding as to why something doesn’t work, it would be very unlikely that an efficient goal can be reached. This same concept applies to research and development projects in the modern day industry. Using the knowledge of recent failures is what drives progress and technological advancements. However, discovering failures is insensitive to time, resources, and capital in an ever changing world of product innovation. If knowledge of research and development failures were known to firms prior towards their attempt, product growth would be quicker, less risky and more profitable. A market that traded intellectual failures would be beneficial towards the firm and its stakeholders while improving market efficiency. Since understanding failures is so important towards the progression and advancement of a product, there should be a market in which firms can trade R&D failures. However, this market does not exist. Yet, if we can argue that there are advantages for firms to possess more intellectual knowledge, than this market can have hypothetical value. One of the main reasons why there is currently no market for R&D trading is because it can be advantageous towards a firm’s competition even at a cost. If competitors...

Words: 3313 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Asymmetric Information & Market Failure

...|Discuss the reasons why asymmetric information can be a source of market failure. Use examples to illustrate your answers. | |By Andrew Sweeting | |November 1998 | |Introduction | |This essay is concerned with the issue of information in microeconomics, particularly where information is a factor in the failure of| |individual markets in an economy. Economic information and its importance in microeconomics is initially discussed, and continues | |with defining asymmetric information, which is a factor that can lead to a market failure. | |In the analysis of asymmetric information in markets, ex ante and ex post asymmetries information are discussed in relation to market| |transactions. Ex ante asymmetric information can be explained through Adverse Selection in relation to quality of goods in the | |product market, and ex post asymmetric information can be explained through Moral Hazard in insurance markets. Strategies to correct | |market failure(s) caused by these information asymmetries is addressed for each example discussed. ...

Words: 1028 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Market Failure

...14, 2012 Economics Essay – Market Failure 1. Markets fail when they under or over allocate resources of production or consumption, relative to the best interests of society. Market failure occurs due to four main factors: the existence of externalities, asymmetric information, the abuse of monopoly power, and inequalities and wealth and development. The existence of externalities means that the market mechanism does not always work efficiently. Markets run on a mechanism that only takes into account the private benefit and cost for a good. Besides the marginal private cost and marginal private benefit, there are the marginal social cost and marginal social benefit, which are external. As a result, governments must find responses to try to solve these market failures. 2. Externalities are the effects of market activities on other people that are external to the market. They are either positive externalities or negative externalities. When the social benefit of a good equates the social cost, it is known as the social optimum. Goods that have large positive externalities can either be public goods or merit goods. Public goods are non-rivalrous and non-excludable, while private goods, such as a merit good, are rivalrous and excludable. When a good has large positive externalities, the government should support its production. When a good has large negative externalities (demerit good), the government should limit or stop its production and consumption. Markets can fail......

Words: 1706 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Market Failure

...Situation 1: The motorcycle helmet market has 13 companies, and four firm concentration ratio of 26%. While the helmets have a variety of designs, they are sold at very similar prices. Recently, the death rate from head injuries in motorcycle crashes has been rising. The producers advertise their helmets as “effective,” but some helmets withstand most falls and others are produced with materials that are more likely to crack in commonly experienced falls. The weaker helmets cost about $8 less to produce. There is no simple way for consumers to determine helmet safety. a) This is a case of market failure caused by externalities emanating from some production agents of the helmets producing lower quality hence weaker helmets while still pricing them at the same price level as the safer, higher quality helmets. This causes a high negative production externality as the consumers will eventually lump all helmets as unsafe, which will negatively affect the other companies as the consumers cannot determine easily the safety of the different brands of helmets. Thus, the consumers may opt to forego riding motorcycles altogether. b) Since the producing agents of the weaker helmets are only considering maximizing the profits at the expense of quality and safety, they do not take into consideration the social costs associated with the use of weaker helmets. Initially, the production agents for these weaker helmets will receive high marginal benefits than marginal costs due to...

Words: 2154 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Market Failure

...Market Failure An Economic Analysis of its Causes and Consequences Vani K. Borooah * Professor of Applied Economics University of Ulster February 2003 * School of Economics and Politics, University of Ulster, Newtownabbey BT37 0QB, Northern Ireland (VK.Borooah@ulst.ac.uk). I am grateful to the Department of Finance and Personnel (Northern Ireland) for supporting this work though, needless to add, I alone am responsible for the contents of this paper and, indeed, for any of its deficiencies. 1. Introduction Much of economic theory of the textbook variety is a celebration of the free market system. This celebration has two parts. First, the operation of the price system, in the context of competitive markets, leads to balance between the demand and supply of the different goods and services traded. In other words, flexible prices result in competitive markets clearing. Second, the market- clearing equilibrium - brought about through flexible prices and competitive markets - is a "good thing" in the sense that it is also a point of economic efficiency1. In other words competitive outcomes are also efficient ones. The fact that competition leads to efficiency is known as the First Fundamental Theorem of Welfare Economics2. These results - which are, of course, a vindication of Adam Smith's intuition about the existence of an "invisible hand" bringing consistency and order to the chaos of individual actions - would be remarkable in themselves. But there is more. The......

Words: 14595 - Pages: 59

Premium Essay

Market Failure of Textile Industry

...Market Failure It occurs when the forces of market fails to allocate resources efficiently. Some causes of market failure include imperfect competition, external costs, etc. Our focus will be on external cost and how Bangladesh’s textile industry has contributed to market failure. Overview of Bangladesh’s Textile Industry Textile industry is the second largest industry in the world next to agriculture. Bangladesh has emerged, in just under a decade, as the twelfth largest textile manufacturing nation in the world. This industry has been one of the most success stories of Bangladesh over the last two decades. Textile industries are one of the largest and vital industrial sectors of Bangladesh with regard to earning foreign exchange and labor employment, providing 4.5 million jobs of which 80% are women and contributes 13% to GDP. A huge 78 percent of the country’s export earnings come from textiles and apparel, according to the latest figures available. Bangladesh exports its apparel products worth nearly $5 billion per year to the United States, European Union, Canada and other countries of the world. It is the sixth largest apparel supplier to the United States and EU countries. Combined, the textile and apparel sectors consist of 3,600 firms. There is a concentration of manufacturing activity in and around the capital city of Dhaka and a growing garment manufacturing presence in the country’s export processing zones. Environmental hazard arising from textile......

Words: 1814 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Economic Failure

...reasons are often inter-related, and often overlap each other, the enormity of which caused the company to fall like a stack of dominoes. In particular, information asymmetry was allowed to flourish as the WorldCom executives lavished themselves with huge compensation, all the while keeping the board of directors and investors out of the loop. A poor corporate government structure existed as the board was filled with inept and ineffective individuals who were powerless to stop the pilfering of profits. The end result of these actions can be seen in how the former employees of WorldCom have been victimized the hardest, in terms of their pensions being gutted, as a result of corporate greed. Agency theory will be used to explain how this failure occurred in terms of information asymmetry, specifically moral hazard, and adverse selection in the relationships between the principal (WorldCom Controller and C.F.O) and agents namely, investors and WorldCom employees. In conclusion, a summary of the various arguments as well as outlining several important lessons that can be learned, so as to avoid future scandals like WorldCom from reoccurring. The importance of accounting conceptual framework Before we head into the details of the WorldCom scandal, we should understand the role of accounting conceptual framework in preventing such scandals from reoccurring again. An accounting conceptual framework can be defined as: “a coherent system of inter-related objectives and......

Words: 3002 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Market Failure

...Market Failure Market Failure generally is the outcome of market’s not being ‘economically efficient’ along with numerous factors helping account for this. If a market begins to saturate or for example a business begins to enjoy monopoly power in their market, the Government can therefore intervene to help make the market more competitive resulting in benefits for both consumers and the economy. Public Goods A reason why government intervention may be necessary is due to their not being enough Public Goods provided by the free market. Public goods such as Street Lights and Public Parks are both non-excludable, where it is not possible to provide a good to one person without it being able to another, and also non-rivalry, where the consumption of a good will not prevent another from enjoying it as well. For these reasons, it is unlikely that a public sector organisation will be able to accommodate for Public Goods, this is why Government action needs to be taken to make them available which is generally funded through taxation. Merit Goods Another reason why government intervention may need to be taken is due to Merit Goods. These are goods that the government feels that if left to themselves without intervention, they will be under-consumed and have to be subsided. If things such as education was not funded for, the government feels that people will not make use of it and in this example, student would just drop out, resulting in their being less......

Words: 456 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Market Failure

...What Determines the Supply for a Good or Service in a Market? ________________________________________________________ Shape of the Supply Curve It slopes upwards for two reasons: 1) Rising prices provide an incentive for firms to produce higher quantities. 2) Law of Diminishing Returns – production costs are higher as higher quantities are produced so producers need to charge consumers more. Movement along the Supply Curve Increased P Increased S : expansion/extension of supply. Decreased P Decreased S : contraction of supply. Shifts in the Supply Curve Shift outwards – increase in supply. Shift inwards – decrease in supply. Non price determinants of supply cause shifts: 1) Production Costs – increased costs lead to decreased supply and an inward shift. 2) Technology – new technology leads to increased efficiency and decreased costs of production – outward shift in the S curve. 3) Indirect Taxation – increase production costs and decrease supply – specific tax (fixed amount per unit) and ad valorem tax (percentage of total price e.g. VAT. Specific Tax: Ad Valorem Tax: 4) Subsidies – decrease costs of production – increase S. 5) Producer Cartels – group together to control P and Q of a good – illegal in the UK. E.g. OPEC (organisation of petroleum exporting countries) can increase or......

Words: 477 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Market Failure - Economics

...Q1. Market failure occurs when resources are not allocated in the most efficient way to achieve highest possible social welfare. In a free market society certain goods and services would not be provided by the private sector as they would not be profitable enough for the companies producing them. As a result, society as a whole would suffer. The government steps in to provide the goods and services required by society that private firms will not provide. These public goods include street lighting, emergency services and public spaces eg parks. These services are paid for by the government which collects the funds through taxation. Merit goods are also funded or subsidised by the government. These are goods or services which people would generally not choose to pay for or think to save for which the government thinks are important ie education, libraries, NHS medical treatment. In the UK every child has the right to an education but many households would not be in a position to pay for it. Likewise, before all prescriptions were free in Scotland, there were still some who qualified for free prescription which were funded by the government ie low income households including those in receipt of certain benefits, elderly people of pension age, and children under the age of 16 or 16 and 17 year olds who were still in education. The presence of externalities can contribute to market failure where the actions of a firm leads to a greater social cost ie the presence of lead in......

Words: 1051 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Market Failures

...Market Failures by Erik F. Meinhardt This section sets out to define and describe market failures, how government intervention prevents them or minimizes their effects, and the arguments against government intervention. I. Definitions and descriptions Market failure occurs when free markets do not bring about economic efficiency, that is to say when a Pareto sub-optimal allocation of resources exists in a particular economy. Market failures remain one of the best reasons for government intervention within an economy on moral and economic grounds, arguably, in the best interest of the public. The following are detailed descriptions of several market failures in no particular order: A. Public goods—Public goods are goods wherein the consumption of them does not necessarily prevent another person from also consuming it, nor does that consumption make less of the good available for consumption by others. Scholars commonly present breathable air as an example of a public good for virtually everyone has access to consume it and its consumption does not limit the amount available. Public goods pose a problem for the market because by their nature it cannot provide for them. The private sector will not make a profit from a good which everyone can enjoy whether or not they pay for it. The lighthouse example comes to mind: no matter who pays for the construction of a lighthouse on a particular island, every passing ship will benefit from the protection it provides and...

Words: 1536 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Market Failure

...Immobility * Occurs when barriers between markets prevent factors of production moving from one area to another to find employment * Land is completely immobile and certain types of capital, for examples factory buildings, can only be moved with extreme difficulty and cost. * Usually geographical immobility refers to the ease or difficulty of labour moving between different areas of the country, or between countries. Factors for geographical immobility: 1. Financial costs in moving home 2. Cost of selling house and removal expenses 3. Large regional variation in house prices which leads to a shortage of affordable housing. 4. Family and Social Ties 5. Immigration controls and language differences Occupational Immobility * Arises when workers lack the skills to move between different types of employment, and because it would be very expensive and time consuming to train workers to have the necessary skills to switch between certain jobs. * Sometimes training is not available and some workers lack the aptitude of taking on different types of employment. * For example, workers made redundant in the coal mining industry lack the specific skills that are needed in growing industries such as the provision of financial services. * All this leads to unemployment and a waste of scarce resources, and contribute to market failure in factor markets. Information Failure * Information failure occurs when people have inaccurate,......

Words: 589 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Nhs-Market Failure

...Topic Two: Market Failure The healthcare system in Britain is predominantly paid for by the Government, and has done now for a number of years, through taxes paid for by the public. In contract the United States, the health care system is part of a free-market economy. This means that when a member of the US public is in need of health care, they must pay for it themselves, with no government help. For example, Sloman (2007) gives a distinct definition to a free market economy, ‘An economy where all economic decisions are taken by individual households and firms with no government intervention’ If healthcare was to be funded completely through a free-market economy, a lot of individuals would say that it would be a relatively fair way of providing each person in need of care, quality treatment. The website Patient UK (2009) cited that ‘1 in 16 hospital admissions are due to alcohol related illnesses’. This strong statistic would reveal that the majority of people in Britain are paying taxes towards the NHS to pay for the care needed for ever-growing amount of people seeking treatment for injuries and illnesses, they most likely would not obtain if they hadn’t got so intoxicated. In some cases, some members of the public in need of the treatment are in fact those of the British public seeking benefits for the Government, so in turn are not only looking for tax payers to for their living benefits but also healthcare. It could be said that the healthier members of the......

Words: 1399 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Market Failure

...Running head: CASE OF TCL & ALCATEL Market Failure Paper: Case of TCL and Alcatel Joint Adventure Jennifer Long Grand Canyon University: ECN 601 April 11, 2012 In the contemporary society, many multinational enterprises would like to use joint venture as their favorite entry mode due to its unique advantages, such as: directly access to the partner’s knowledge, sharing development costs and risks. Meanwhile, it is important to figure out the factors that will cause failure of a joint venture. Some major factors are culture difference, poor leadership and insufficient planning which are all fatal to the operation of joint venture. Cultural differences have direct influences on international joint venture performance through management practice and organizational learning; poor leadership will result in bad business integration and even wasting the preciously initial funds; insufficient planning may trouble company in the long term. In the article from the China Daily, many Chinese companies are now hoping to utilize global partnerships to make inroads in the major international markets (China Daily, 2011). If a company wants to speed up the expansion, it may decide to use surplus resources or raise further cash by cooperating with another existing business. Joint venture can be defined as an entity formed between two or more parties to undertake economic activity together. Chairman of TCL Corporation explained that TCL was most attracted to......

Words: 978 - Pages: 4