Critical Appraisal Guidelines Part 2

In: Science

Submitted By amandatcreel
Words 1068
Pages 5
Critical Appraisal Guidelines: Qualitative - Part 2
Amanda T. Creel
Grand Canyon University: NRS – 433V
June 9, 2013

The research article reviewed was “Ultrasound – Guided Peripheral Venous Access vs. the External Jugular Vein as the Initial Approach to the Patient with Difficult Vascular Access” by T.G. Costantino MD, J. F. Kirtz MD, and W. A. Satz MD. Intravenous (IV) access is commonly performed in the Emergency Department (ED). In patients with difficult access, physicians are frequently called upon to perform these procedures. Physicians should be familiar with both the external jugular (EJ) IV technique and the ultrasound – guided IV (USIV) peripheral access techniques. Some hospitals have specialized team of nurses that have been educated and trained on the proper way to establish an EJ IV and/or USIV. This study examined both techniques and collected data to establish which techniques was better for the patient.
Protection of Human Participants
Risks and Benefits Addressed by the Authors The benefit of this study was to spare the ED patient with difficult veins from having to receive a central venous line. The infection rate is higher in a central line than a peripheral IV line. The use of USIV will also decrease the number or IV attempts instead of a central line. While this decreased the actual number of IV attempts, it still had some risks. One major risk is arterial punctures. The other risks include nerve irritation and hematomas at the site of both USIV and EJ IV attempts.
Consents and Approvals The study was approved by the university’s institutional review board of an urban, tertiary – care university hospital ED. The subjects entered the study voluntarily after being education on the research. After the education process, a written consent was obtained. The patient was then placed in a randomized tract of the study.
Data Collection…...

Similar Documents

Career Development Plan Part 2

...Career Development Plan Part 2 We want to introduce our new sales team that has been put together in the past few weeks to the company’s new strategy and sales program, we have taken the authorization to assign each member to their appropriate training and orientation. I have put together an appraisal performance form so we are able to evaluate the member’s performance of our team, and this will provide feedback so we are able to understand the voice and opinion of the management team from the employees. I will be reviewing each appraisal, and feedback will be given to each team member , feedback will help assist in the future to perform at a top level and if needed will offer educational opportunities. Feedback Feedback is important for the future of our sales team. Feedback is a issue that is based on the personality and character of the employee. We need to make sure that we stay on target and address the performance problems, given information on individual’s performance, discuss the performance that needs to be improved, we need to be critical but not cross the line. Since I am a manager and feedback advisor, we like our communication skills so we are able to guide, train, encourage, teach and refocus our team. I believe that we should give feedback almost once a month, so we can support each other and give the opportunity to communicate solutions to our problems. Performance /Dual Careers I will help the employees to reach a higher level of performance by......

Words: 1090 - Pages: 5

Critical Appraisal of Guideline

...Critical Appraisal of Guideline   Critical Appraisal of Guideline Appraisal Tool The tool chosen to appraise the guideline is called the AGREE II ( The purpose of the AGREE II is to examine the quality of guidelines through a step-by-step approach as to what and how information is presented in a guideline. The step-by-step approach is completed via twenty three steps which are categorized into 6 domains. Domain one addresses the overall scope and purpose of the guideline. Domain two is concerned with the stakeholders’ involvement and how the intended users view the guideline. Domain three pertains to the rigor of development of the guideline through eight steps which cover the method of evidence synthesis. Domain four deals with the clarity of the presentation throughout the guideline. Domain five is titled applicability, and it focuses on barriers and facilitators in applying the guideline. Domain six is titled editorial independence and evaluates whether the guideline is free from biases. Guideline The guideline chosen for appraisal is Diagnosis and management of headache in adults. A national clinical guideline ( Critique Domain one: The guideline presents evidence-based recommendations for the diagnosis and management of headaches in adults. The health questions covered by the guideline are located in the annex of the ¬¬¬¬¬original guideline, and the target population,......

Words: 1317 - Pages: 6

Critical Appraisal of a Quantitative Study

...CARE WORKERS HAND DECONTAMINATION PRACTICES: A QUANTITATIVE STUDY CRITICAL APPRAISAL: INTRODUCTION: The problem of hospital acquired infection is identified, effort have been made to eradicate or reduce the rates of receiving. The aim of the article notes the study of healthcare workers hand washing practices from behavioural aspect. LITERATURE REVIEW: Researcher analyse various articles that describes the rates of hospital acquired infection that obtained from 6-15% of hospital admission. It also states 10-32% of acquired infection have been found in the intensive care unit (ICU).One of the study claim it is important to understand the rates can be reduced by up to one-third if the healthcare workers go along with the guidelines issued by CDC ( Centers for Disease Control and Prevention).Likewise, the factors that provide to healthcare workers non-compliance with hand washing guidelines have been identified ,such as inaccessible equipment, lack of time, busyness and deleterious effects on skin. Intervention to improve such as provision of an educational programmes, motivational programme and patient educational programmes have been enabled. After all, the researchers have concluded the hand washing compliance rates of health workers are difficult to change, therefore it can be argued that maintained improvement of compliance with guidelines requires a multi-faceted approach. THEORETICAL......

Words: 917 - Pages: 4

Critical Appraisal

...psycho-educational program that aids the nursing profession to develop plans for stress management. The purpose of the project appears to be valid and the design of the project appears to answer the purpose of the project. References Houck, G., Kendall, J., Miller, A., Morrell, P., & Wiebe, G. (2011). Self-concept in children and adolescents with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Journal of Pediatric Nursing, 26(3), 239-247. Retrieved from CINAHL database on July 2, 2014. Imes, C.C., Dougherty, C.M., Pyper, G., & Sullivan, M.D. (2011). Descriptive study of partners’ experiences of living with severe heart failure. Heart & Lung: The Journal of Critical Care, 40(3), 208-216. Retrieved from CINAHL database on July 2, 2014. Kravis, K., McAllister-Black, R., Grant, M., & Kirk, C. (2010). Self-care strategies for nurses: A psycho-educational intervention for stress reduction and the prevention of burnout. Applied Nursing Research: ANR, 23(3), 130-138. Retrieved from CINAHL database on July 2, 2014....

Words: 609 - Pages: 3

Critical Appraisal #1

...Critical Appraisal #1 of Scott, Hofmeister, Rogness, and Rogers Article The University of Texas at Arlington College of Nursing Shirley McKenzie-Pace In partial fulfillment of the requirements for N5301 Research in Nursing Susan K. Grove, PhD, RN, ANP-BC, GNP-BC July 12, 2014 Critical Appraisal #1 Theoretical Framework The study framework is not clearly identified; however, a tentative theory is proposed since a tentative theory “has had minimal exposure to critique by the discipline, and has had little testing, (Burns and Grove, 2009). The conceptual framework is limited to the model impaired sleep. The linking of the concept impaired sleep to independent variables of the fatigue countermeasures program for nurses (FCMPN). The FCMPN in this study was “modeled after the National Aeronautics and Space Administration Ames Research Center’s Fatigue Countermeasures Program and the Sleep, Alertness, and Fatigue Education in Residency Program” (Scott et al., 2010, p. 253). The major study concepts include: “sleep deprivation (inadequate sleep), sleep disruption (fragmented sleep), lifestyle situation, and health related issues” (p. 251). There is no map or model of the impaired sleep model purposed by Lee et al., 2004 (as cited in Scott et al., 2010) in the article; however, there is a diagram of the conceptual framework for the FCMPN. Variable Identification and Definitions The research variables that Scott et al. (2010) observed and measured were the FCMPN, ......

Words: 2429 - Pages: 10

Critical Analysis of a Quantitative Study Part 2

...Write a critical analysis of a quantitative study that demonstrates comprehension of the research study conducted. Each study analysis will be 750-1,000 words and submitted in one document. Questions under each heading should be addressed as a narrative, in the structure of a formal paper. Include the following: I.  An introduction to the article. II.  Protection of human participants, including: * Identify the benefits and risks of participation addressed by the authors. Were there benefits or risks the authors do not identify? * Was informed consent obtained from the subjects or participants? * Did it seem that the subjects participated voluntarily in the study? * Was institutional review board approval obtained from the agency in which the study was conducted? 1. Assessing study tools. 2. Addressing ethical issues. III.  Data collection methods, their critique, potential biases and ethical issues thereof. * Are the major variables (independent and dependent variables) identified and defined? What were these variables? * How were data collected in this study? * What rationale did the author provide for using this data collection method? * Identify the time period for data collection of the study. * Describe the sequence of data collection events for a participant. IV. Problem statement: 1. Problem statement is clearly stated. 2. Provides justification for the study. 3. Topic is significant to nursing. 4....

Words: 451 - Pages: 2

Critical Thinking Lecture 2

...Lecture 2 and Mid-term expectations Class structure 10am-1pm 10-10.20 Homework 10.20-11.30 Quiz below 11.30-11.50 Break 11.50-12.45 Euthyphro 12.45-1.00 Mid-term expectations Homework for Femke – reading and understanding how you reason – describe how you approach a problem . Step-by-step process . Quiz 1. A = Valid Socrates is a philosopher All philosophers are poor So Socrates is poor 2. A – iv Whenever Anile is here, Kumar is also here Anil is not here So Kumar is not here 3. A = iv Most drug addicts are depressed people Most depressed people are lonely So most drug addicts are lonely 4. A= v Nothing that s cheap is good So nothing that is good is cheap 5. A = v If there is an earthquake , the detector will send a message No message has been sent So there was no message 6. A = iv John said that everyone loves Mary Nothing that John has said is true So nobody loves Mary Mid-term This assignment is designed to assess your critical thinking problem solving, and communication skills. Your answer will be judged for its clarity, relevance, coherence, logic, depth, consistency, and fairness. Your answers to each issue should be between 700-800 words in length. More specifically, the reader will be asking the following questions: 1. Is the question at issue well stated? Is it clear and unbiased? Does the expression of the question do justice to the complexity of the matter at issue?  2.......

Words: 1681 - Pages: 7

Proj 598 - Part 2

...implementing a website, is extensive and growing. We provide a whole solution to the problem at hand not just a product. Task 1 – Kick Off Meeting As with each and every project our company will send over some of our staff to visit your company/department to better understand the full needs and goals of each project. We will be sending a Project Manager (myself) and two of our senior staff. The purpose of which is to establish a working process that works within your ramifications and guidelines. During the meeting we will discuss the timeline of needs and milestones as well as the expectations of deliverable such as but not limited to: * Research and Reports * Design and Printed Materials * Digital Deliverables * ETC This early meeting will allow us maintain focus on the work efforts throughout the life of the project. The team will use this time to ask questions and ensure that we understand your current and future plans to allow us to build for now and then. Task 2 – Project Management Plan Antoine Stephenson, the Project Manager, has worked on a number of diverse and unique projects with companies ranging from small/medium businesses to Fortune 100 companies. With this breadth of knowledge and experience He will be able to guide your project from start to finish. Providing a liaison between your management team and the lead developers and Quality assurance personnel here at Twanworks Inc. Derrick Morton – Lead Designer, has also......

Words: 2345 - Pages: 10

Research Critique, Part 2

...Research Critique, Part 2 Introduction to Nursing of Nursing Nursing 433v October 26, 2013 Research Critique, Part 2 Introduction Improving patient satisfaction has been the forefront of nursing for the past decade. Many studies have been executed to assess practice and procedures that will improve patient satisfaction and patient safety. Nursing leadership and bedside nursing staff play a pivotal role in transforming bedside nursing. A critical appraisal was conducted in Australia by Gardner, Woollett, Daly, & Richardson, (2009) on measuring the effect of patient comfort rounds on practice environment and patient satisfaction: a pilot study. This research aimed to test the effect of a model of practice that enhanced the role of the assistant-in-nursing (AIN) on a skill mixed unit (Gardner et al, 2009). Gardner et al, 2009 adopted a quasi-experimental pilot study using a non-randomized parallel group trial design. The purpose of this paper is to identify if hourly rounding will upturn patient safety and satisfaction during their hospitalization. Protection of Human Participants. The authors of this study did not disclose any risk related to the study, however, one main benefit is this is a pilot study assessing techniques and tools for a larger study in the future. The piolet was regulated over an eight week span within a matched surgical unit including an experimental and control group. The intervention unit includes a sample of 61 consenting patients and 23...

Words: 959 - Pages: 4

Critical Appraisal

...Critical Appraisal 1Faith Rodriguez BSN-RNNURS5326: Research for Advanced Nursing PracticeSeptember 21, 2015Dr. Jana Saunders | Name and describe the theory that is used in your assigned primary research article. (1 paragraph) | The theory of self-regulation is the theoretical base and method in the research study to examine the use of emotion regulation and goal-directed behavior in an attempt to improve sleep behaviors. Self-regulation is the process in which a person has perceived illness cognition, a patient’s own implicit common sense beliefs about their illness. There are five cognitive dimensions of these beliefs: identity; perceived cause of illness; time line; consequences; curability and controllability (Fowler, Kirschner, Kuiken, & Baas., 2007, p. 223). This process occurs over three stages of interpretation, coping, and appraisal (Fowler et al., 2007). In the research study, “Using Mental Imagery to Deliver Self-Regulation Techniques to Improve Sleep Behaviors,” the efficacy of behavioral interventions were geared toward improving the sleep behavior for working adults with the use of mental imagery undertakings that were designed with the theory of self-regulation principles. More specifically, the main attitude is where the patient focuses their thoughts, emotions, and behavior in order to achieve their desired outcome, a sort of homeostasis, if you will. The use of imagery and implementation intention imagery are used in order to......

Words: 883 - Pages: 4

Nt2650 Project Part 2

...Joshua Rivas NT2580 Project Part 2 Purpose - This policy defines the security configurations users and Information Technology (IT) administrators are required to implement in order to ensure the integrity, availability, and confidentially of the network environment of Richmond Investments(R.I). It serves as the central policy document with which all employees and contractors must be familiar, and defines regulations that all users must follow. The policy provides IT managers within R.I. with policies and guidelines concerning the acceptable use of R.I. technology equipment, e-mail, Internet connections, network resources, and information processing. The policies and restrictions defined in this document shall apply to all network infrastructures and any other hardware, software, and data transmission mechanisms. This policy must be adhered to by all R.I. employees, temporary workers and by vendors and contractors working with R.I. Scope- This policy document defines the common security requirements for all R.I. personnel and systems that create, maintain, store, access, process or transmit information. This policy also applies to information resources owned by others, such as vendors or contractors of R.I., in cases where R.I. has a legal obligation to protect resources while in R.I. possession. This policy covers all of R.I. network systems which are comprised of various hardware, software, communication equipment and other devices designed to assist the R.I. in the......

Words: 1956 - Pages: 8

A Critical Appraisal of Motivational Practices

...1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.1 TITLE A Critical Appraisal of the Motivational Practices employed within the NLS environment. 1.2 Organizational Background The NLS organization can be considered a large statutory authority that provides information services within the context of education. 1.2.1 Problem Definition Several factors currently affect the NLS employee at the individual level that impact on his or her performance as a service provider. Motivation is as crucial to NLS employees as to any other. There is an inherent problem of low motivation among the staff of the NLS that is reflected in below average employee productivity, high rates of absenteeism and turnover, low morale and an unwillingness to give extra effort. Thus, it is important to understand the fundamental needs and desires of NLS employees which can be manipulated and stimulated to achieve positive motivation. As argued by Almer, Higgs and Hooks (2005), there are factors other than pay that motivate individuals to work in organisations. 1.2.2 Research Question To what extent do motivational strategies affect organisational efficiency at the NLS and what approaches can be undertaken to improve them in the future. 1.3 Methodology This paper will attempt to identify key factors of motivation for NLS employees and proffer an explanation of how to adequately motivate them to contribute an optimal effort to the organisation’s objectives. This will be accomplished by the use of secondary data,......

Words: 1398 - Pages: 6

Project Appraisal 2

...– LECTURE 2 1. QUESTION: Find point price elasticity, point income elasticity and point cross-price elasticity at P=10, Y=20, and Ps=9, if the demand function were estimated to be: Qd = 90 – 8.P + 2.Y + 2.Ps Is the demand for this product elastic or inelastic? Is it a luxury or a necessity? Does this product have a close substitute or complement? Find the point elasticity of demand. 2. ANSWER: | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | Q2 – Q1 P2 Q2 P1 – P2 QD = 90 – 8P + 2Y + 2P = 90 – 8(10) + 2 (20) + 2 (9) QD = 90 – 80 + 40 + 18 = 68 Quantity of the good. Point elasticity = QD = 90 – 8P Demand curve = QD = 90 – 8P Q 10 -80 -8 - = -8 = = P 90 90 9 Income Elasticity = % Q If Y = 0, QD = 90 % Y QD = 90 + 2Y Q = = 2......

Words: 509 - Pages: 3

Part 2

...Amanda Raby 5/18/16 “Logic and Set Theory” Part # 1 The intersection gives only what the two sets have in common. The union of two sets is the set of elements which are in either set. The intersection of two sets is the set of elements which is in both sets. Make sense right? At times there will not be any intersection at all, this would be called an empty or null set. The intersection gives you only what the two sets have in common whereas the union combines the sets. With the union we can retrieve records from both database sets, being able to access all of each set of records but when using the intersection of the database sets you can only access the records that meet both conditions. Some examples may include the following (Something I can think of): After doing some reading I figure that most everyday things we encounter is ran through a database. When you access a database, often you want to recover only records with certain features. The records with these features can be treated as a set. For example, one set is all children born in the state of Maryland and the other set is all children born with Red hair in the U.S. When you use the union of both sets we include all children in the state of Maryland and all children born with Red hair nationwide. This will includes all of both sets, but when......

Words: 500 - Pages: 2

Critical Appraisal

...t Critical Appraisal # 1 Theoretical Framework a. The study framework was clearly identified as Bandura‟s (1986) Self-Efficacy Theory, which is a substantive theory (Burns & Grove, 2009). b. The discussion of the framework is limited with the linking of the concept of self-efficacy to the independent variable of the nurse-coached IMT. No model of the framework is provided. The major study concepts include: situational demands, vicarious experiences, verbal persuasion, enactive attainment, performance accomplishment, and enhanced self-efficacy. Variable Identification and Definitions Independent variable: Home-based nurse coached IMT Intervention Conceptual definition: “Bandura‟s Self-Efficacy Theory guided the intervention for the experimental group (IMT)… Vicarious experiences for the IMT group were accomplished by observing the demonstration of the tack of using the Threshold Device, thus „modeling‟ the instruction and demonstration provided by the RA. Performance accomplishment was achieved by „mastering‟ the technique of inspiring into the device with a nose clip in place… thus providing tangible evidence of progress” (Padula et al., 2009, p. 21). Operational definition: “The Threshold Device (Healthscan) was used for resistive IMT breathing training… Training consisted of demonstration by the RAs, with return demonstration at baseline followed by a week of device use…” The study intervention was detailed in Padula et al. (2009, p. 20) CRITICAL APPRAISAL......

Words: 506 - Pages: 3